Vision: I love those waves there, white color makes balance with tree in left. Also sky and sands making great feeling. Everything balanced! So I`m giving 4 stars. Originality: everybody needs picture like this... and mostly everybody has it. So I`m giving 2 stars. Technique: No composition here. Photo looks with lot of work on after edit, but then why You didn't fix the composition? So I`m giving 2 stars. Impact: Colors are eye catching, that`s why i give 2,5 stars.
Maybe You can add location of the place in photo? Otherwise i love picture, because of a color balance.
I love this one. The first impression that I get is that I'm lost in some unreal fantasy world. I also get the sense of solitude and emptiness from this art - which is great. Either as a premade BG or stand-alone art, this art is good to mix your feelings.
I also like how it's made. I see some real photo elements and also some painting-like elements. They r great combination. I also like the color of sunset (orange/yellowish). This is a must-use premade BG for all photomanip artists who want a quick way to create sad or serene art.
And, oh, I honestly can't find anything wrong with this art to criticize Overall, great art!